Amid concerns about end-of-semester grade reporting due to striking graduate student employees, an “overwhelming majority” of grades for the University of Michigan’s winter term have been submitted, Provost Laurie McCauley said in a May 8 email message to Ann Arbor campus faculty.
About 91% of total grades had been submitted as of 5 p.m. May 8. That is about 4% behind what is typical at this point following the end of the term.
more information
It is common for a small percentage of grades to be delayed each term. They are most often associated with independent study and study-abroad courses, particularly when a student is receiving a grade from a partner institution.
In her email to faculty, McCauley described some of the hardships students have experienced due to this term’s additional grading delays.
“We have heard from many concerned undergraduates who are facing deadlines for class registration and financial aid, and from many seniors who face grade-reporting deadlines for job and graduate school applications,” she wrote.
“I have asked deans to work with department chairs and faculty to ensure all of them receive grades as soon as possible. Schools and colleges are also taking steps in individual cases, whenever possible, to ensure our students’ future education and plans are not compromised.”
The timely and accurate processing of end-of-semester grades has been an issue of concern due to the strike by the Graduate Employees’ Organization, the union representing approximately 2,300 graduate student instructors and graduate student staff assistants.
The student employees walked off the job March 29, and the union has encouraged its members and other faculty to withhold final grades.
“GEO members collectively decided to withhold grades as part of our strike,” said Amir Fleischmann, GEO Contract Committee chair. “Graduate workers made that decision out of a growing frustration with (Academic Human Resources’) refusal to bargain in good faith and treat the issues grads are facing with the seriousness they deserve. Given that we were not paid for the month of April, there is no reason why the administration should expect us to complete our work obligations.”
In situations where instructors are not available to complete the term, department chairs or other appropriate authorities may appoint alternatives to complete the task, according to university leaders.
In her email message, McCauley thanked “the many faculty and staff who have been instrumental partners as we finish the semester.”
“Many of you have selflessly put in long hours, contacted individual students, and opened dialogue with your colleagues about how to minimize the harm to our students caused by the strike, from loss of classroom instruction to delayed and incomplete grading,” she wrote.
“On behalf of university leadership and the many undergraduates who have contacted our office and others with concerns about course continuity, untaught material, and grades, we are appreciative of the faculty who have worked to meet uncertainty with dedication and ingenuity.”
GEO commits to two more bargaining days in May
The union’s prior contract with the university expired May 3.
With GEO having not announced an end to the strike for the spring semester, a Michigan Employment Relations Commission mediator working with the bargaining teams for GEO and the university has encouraged the two sides to meet as often as possible.
While U-M has offered to meet every weekday throughout May for full days of bargaining, GEO has committed to only two sessions for the remainder of the month, according to McCauley’s email.
“Many in the university community have urged both parties to bargain often and in earnest,” she wrote. “I am extremely concerned about how bargaining can progress with such infrequent sessions.”
Fleischmann said the union had met with the university’s bargaining team as frequently as the state mediator had suggested, but that those meetings were not productive.
“Unlike HR’s bargaining team, ours is not made up of full-time employees making hefty six-figure salaries,” he said. “Instead, our team is made up of graduate students on a volunteer basis. We have other obligations — not least of which is writing our dissertations — and need to take time to focus on that work.
“Our members are aggravated that AHR continues to represent their sub-inflation salary offer — an effective pay cut — as a serious offer. It isn’t. Until AHR is ready to present a serious offer, we do not feel additional bargaining sessions would be a good use of our team’s scarce time.”
U-M and GEO have not reached an agreement on compensation, with the union demanding a 60% pay raise in the first year of its three-year contract. GEO members would earn about $55 per hour next year under the proposal.
The union proposed this raise in November and has not moved from that position despite three counteroffers from the university. Most GEO members are appointed at 50% effort — or about 16-20 hours per week — for two-thirds of the year.
Under the university’s current compensation proposal, GEO members on the Ann Arbor campus would receive 11.5% in total raises over the next three years — 5%, 3.5% and 3% — and make roughly $38-$39 per hour by year three. GEO members currently earn about $35 per hour.
In addition to their earnings, GEO members also receive tuition waivers of up to $12,947 per semester for in-state students and $26,062 per semester for out-of-state students, child-care subsidies that start at $3,043 for one child per semester, and comprehensive health insurance with no monthly premiums.
Lindsay Heagle
Out of curiosity, of the 91% of grades already submitted, how many are legitimate reflections of student performance and how many were falsified in order to achieve a timely submission? Falsified grades might include those related to major deviations in the original syllabus, grading by unrelated staff, or just giving everyone a passing grade.
Jessyca Hannah
When COVID happened and everyone was granted a pass/fail grade, no one batted an eye. How do you know that isn’t happening here given the the GEO refuse to work and put themselves first instead of the students they are supporting?
Lindsay Heagle
The difference between here and COVID is that the University has full control of the situation and has refused to make any serious offers that would motivate GEO to stop the strike. It may not mean anything to you, but the decision to strike was very difficult for many GSI’s, as we knew it had the potential to leave many vulnerable students behind. Indeed, many who chose not to strike did so for their students, not the administration. We care. It is the university that has proven unwilling to negotiate and could have avoided this situation entirely.
Jessyca Hannah
“Given that we were not paid for the month of April, there is no reason why the administration should expect us to complete our work obligations.” – I know this may come as a shock, but if you don’t work, you generally don’t get paid.
I wish that I received free childcare while I was studying and working but alas, I had to pay for it from my salary. I also had to work a fulltime job while working on my Master’s degree. These Grad Students have it rough UM, you should really give into their out-of-touch demands.
Lindsay Heagle
For the record, childcare is not free for graduate students – the few who qualify get a subsidy, and even then they end up spending the majority of their monthly salary on the rest of the bill.
Congrats on receiving your Master’s degree – as a former grad student, you should understand that it’s a stressful time, and have a vested interest in making it better and more accessible for other students. It’s also worth nothing that while working for the University, we are not allowed to work other jobs. The University has the means and opportunity to make life better for its graduate students, and has said verbatim at the table that they “are not interested” in making these changes.
Jennifer Piemonte
Again, we have Don Jordan providing patently false information about GEO.
GEO’s counter offers has indeed moved from 60%, conceding up to $12 million.