Mentioning ‘white privilege’ increases online polarization

Topics:

If there’s an online discussion about race, using the term “white privilege” can create a polarized situation, University of Michigan researchers say.

The mention of white privilege can create internet discussions that are less constructive, more polarized and less supportive of racially progressive policies, said Christopher Quarles, a doctoral student in the School of Information and the study’s lead author.

MORE INFORMATION

With online political polarization on the rise, and race at the forefront of today’s news, it is important to make cross-cultural online communication effective and inclusive, he said.

In a study published in PLOS ONE, Quarles and co-author Lia Bozarth, also a School of Information doctoral student, looked at how language used in online discussions impacts who participates in them and how they respond. These, in turn, can influence perceptions of public opinion.

Specifically, the study examined how the term “white privilege” — whose origins existed as early as the 1980s but became widely used in the last decade’s heightened racial tension — affects online communication.

The study does not directly examine the concept of white privilege itself, or whether whites think they have advantages due to their race. Instead, the goal was to look at how use of the term affected online behavior.

In two lab experiments, nearly 1,000 U.S. residents — of whom 82% were white — were given a chance to respond to a post asking their opinions about renaming college buildings. Using the term “white privilege” in the question decreased the percentage of whites who supported renaming, the research indicated.

In addition, whites who remained supportive when “white privilege” was mentioned were less likely to create an online post, while opposing whites and nonwhites showed no significant difference. The term also led to more low-quality posts among both whites and nonwhites, Quarles said.

The relationship between question language and the content of the responses was mediated by their support or opposition to renaming buildings. This suggests that, rather than causing people to think differently about the world, the term “white privilege” causes an emotional reaction that then affects their response, Quarles said.

Inclusive ways of speaking about race online, such as the term “racial inequality,” are more likely to create a sense of shared purpose, he said. Policymakers who want to promote racial equity should consider how their language can either unite people or alienate potential allies, he said.

“There are very real racial inequities in society today. Choosing language that promotes constructive conversation will not solve those problems,” Quarles said. “But it is an important step toward collectively understanding their dimensions and working together toward a solution.”

Tags:

Comments

  1. Tina Ronders
    on May 6, 2022 at 7:25 am

    I have no way of knowing what it feels like to check the box with anything other than “caucasian/white”. I was born a descendant of ancestors who came to America looking for a better life. Because of this, I had, have and will always have privilege just by being born white. It is not something I brag over; it’s just a fact. Regardless of that, I dedicate myself to support anyone I meet with respect, dignity and [sisterly] love regardless of skin color, ethnicity, citizenship, religion, or gender identity. Any differences we may have can not predict how I treat others. We do have to talk about it before healing can begin. We all bleed the same and are part of the single race: Human.

  2. Kirk Lawrence
    on May 6, 2022 at 9:09 am

    This article could to a catalyst for so many other sub-categorical thoughts and comments from all of us. This term of ‘white-privilege’ has (in my opinion) the same negative conditioning as ‘minority’. I have consistently thought and spoken against that term (minority) because the very use of that word sounds as if someone is less than/smaller/etc. Sadly, inequalities have been with us since the dawn of time and will likely remain. It’s up to all of us to make a difference in our own backyard(s).

    Just as Tina has said, I too treat anyone with the utmost respect and dignity. We should always be on the lookout for those who are treated indifferently and help them to rise above…whatever that looks like. I take my status in life with the utmost responsibility of being a helping hand and never a hindrance.

Leave a comment

Please read our comment guidelines.