University of Michigan
News for Faculty and Staff

September 22, 2018

U-M expert talks ‘Star-Spangled Banner’ myths, baseball, Jimi Hendrix

June 30, 2015

U-M expert talks ‘Star-Spangled Banner’ myths, baseball, Jimi Hendrix

As Independence Day approaches, one of America's foremost experts on "The Star-Spangled Banner" talks about the history of the U.S. national anthem and projects surrounding the bicentennial year of its anniversary.

Mark Clague, associate professor of music at the School of Music, Theatre & Dance, is the founding board chair of the Star Spangled Music Foundation and the editor and producer of the Star Spangled Songbook and its associated recording project, Poets & Patriots: A Tuneful History of "The Star-Spangled Banner."

Q: What does "The Star-Spangled Banner" mean to you? What prompted your research?

Clague: Some of my earliest childhood memories are of decorating my bicycle for a neighborhood parade to celebrate the U.S. bicentennial in 1976 (I was nine years old). So, I caught patriotic fever then. On a more practical level, I use the anthem in my music history classes to inspire students to think more deeply about the role of music in their daily lives. To showcase this, I wanted to have a recording of the anthem as Francis Scott Key might have heard it (in 1814, the song was faster and had a repeating chorus). Amazingly I couldn't find anything stylistically appropriate, so I made just such a recording with my students here at the University of Michigan that premiered in February 2014.

Q: Your scholarship led you to found StarSpangledMusic.org and the Star Spangled Music Foundation last year in honor of the song's 200th birthday, and part of its mission is to provide curricular materials to K-12 teachers. Why do you think that is this important?

Clague: I think music is fundamental to human life and "The Star-Spangled Banner" is a great example of a song that speaks to the very nature of who we are as a nation, who we are as citizens. Key's first verse ends with a question mark. He is searching for the answer not only to the question of the flag and America's immediate future, but to questions about freedom and the distant future. These are questions that students — as our future citizens — need to answer for their generation. Historically, Key's words have helped us figure out what it means to be American, and I think that K-12 teachers, be they history, literature, social studies, art or music teachers, are working with their students to answer these same questions every day

Q: You often write about "Banner myth-conceptions." What is the most common fact that people misconstrue?

Clague: Probably that Francis Scott Key wrote a song, not a poem. He used a well known popular melody—"To Anacreon in Heaven"—as the musical vehicle to express his joy and relief after the U.S. victory at the Battle of Baltimore on Sept. 14, 1814. So, he crafted the words intentionally to fit this tune; music and text are thus expressively intertwined. Key wrote the lyric with the tune already in his mind's ear. In fact, he had used the same melody nine years earlier for another American patriotic song, "When the Warrior Returns."

Q: Are there still any mysteries? Information yet to be discovered?

Clague: There is so much more to discover about the anthem, Francis Scott Key, and especially how Americans have used the song as a sounding board to dream of a more perfect union. We think of the song and Key's text as singular today, but there were literally hundreds of different words published in the 19th century that fit this melody. These texts honored George Washington, helped elect Abraham Lincoln, protested the existence of slavery, fought for women's rights and celebrated the Fourth of July holiday.

Q: Do you have a favorite version(s)?

Clague: I think Jimi Hendrix's Woodstock Banner has to be one of the deepest and most profound renditions ever, but I love so many performances. Whitney Houston's performance at the Super Bowl in 1991 is maybe the most soaring and inspiring, and I love every time the Michigan Marching Band plays it for pregame at the Big House. For me, it's less about the precise details of the musical arrangement or how much personalized ornamentation some megastar might add, instead it's about how heartfelt and expressive it is. Singing the anthem always makes an identity claim. Flexibility in performance gives the singer the opportunity to say something personal, meaningful and inspirational.

10 Quick Star-Spangled Facts:

"The Star-Spangled Banner," as Francis Scott Key's song is now known, was written in mid-September 1814 to celebrate the defeat of the British navy at the Battle of Baltimore during the War of 1812. We are currently in the midst of its bicentennial year.

Before it was named "The Star-Spangled Banner," it was titled "The Defence of Fort McHenry." The name we know today appears in the first sheet music imprint published in October/November 1814 and helped broaden the appeal of the song to the entire nation.

During the Civil War, Union supporters used a German translation of the song to recruit German-speakers to volunteer for the militia. Since then, Key's lyric has been translated into more than a dozen languages.

The anthem was first played at a professional sporting event in 1862 in Brooklyn, New York, where a band had been hired to celebrate the opening of a new baseball stadium. It was performed at the first World Series in 1903 in Boston.

It wasn't until 1931 that Key's song became the official anthem of the U.S. by act of Congress. Prohibitionists, nationalists, pacifists and even music teachers opposed the choice, suggesting alternatives including "Hail Columbia" and "America, the Beautiful."

Why did music teachers protest? The tune is indeed a strange choice for a national anthem. Its melodic compass from lowest note to highest is an octave plus a fifth (known to musicians as a twelfth) making the melody awkward at best for group singing — and a musical feat for a soloist.

Women played a major role in the anthem's adoption. The Daughters of the War of 1812 were major advocates of the 1931 act of Congress that President Hoover signed. As causes go, this was a safe arena in which women could engage in political activism in the early 20th century.

There is not technically an original, traditional or otherwise official version of "The Star-Spangled Banner." While some state laws have attempted to legislate appropriate performance style and demeanor, no single official standard exists.

Psychedelic rock guitarist Jimi Hendrix performed the anthem in concert at least 60 times, though most know only his famous rendition at the 1969 Woodstock Festival.

The anthem has four verses, but we only sing one. Oliver Wendell Holmes Sr., an influential writer from Boston, actually added a fifth verse in 1861 with new words advocating that American slaves be unchained.

Comments

Jennifer Sporer
on 7/01/15 at 8:39 am

What a great article. I will definitely listen to Jimi Hendrix's rendition this weekend.

Brian Morgan
on 7/01/15 at 9:34 am

I would also suggest the version by Madison Rising (madisonrising.com).

Patti Fitzpatrick
on 7/02/15 at 11:13 am

I would personally like to see us adopt "America the Beautiful" as our national anthem. I find the "Star-Spangled Banner" too difficult to sing and too militaristic.

Kate McAlpine
on 7/06/15 at 1:15 pm

Was no one complaining about the respectability of a national anthem sung to the tune of a drinking song?

Commenting is closed for this article. Please read our comment guidelines for more information.